What happens if your car is a lemon in California?

Owning a vehicle is meant to be a source of convenience and freedom, but what happens when the car you've invested in turns out to be less than reliable? This is where the California Lemon Law comes into play, offering crucial protection for consumers grappling with persistent defects in their vehicles. Enacted in 1970 and officially known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, the California Lemon Law serves as a formidable shield against the frustration and inconvenience of owning a defective car.

This law applies to both new and used vehicles sold or leased with a manufacturer's warranty, extending its protective umbrella to a wide range of consumers. Whether it's a new car with unending issues or a used vehicle sold with an existing warranty, the California Lemon Law is designed to ensure that consumers have avenues for resolution when faced with automotive woes.

Recognizing a Lemon

Criteria for Classifying a Vehicle as a Lemon

1. Repetitive Defects:

A fundamental criterion is the presence of repetitive defects or issues that impact the vehicle's performance, safety, or value. These defects can manifest in various components such as the engine, transmission, brakes, steering, or other critical systems.

2. Safety Hazards:

The law places significant emphasis on safety. If the defects pose a risk to the safety of the driver, passengers, or others on the road, it strengthens the case for classifying the vehicle as a lemon.

3. Substantial Impairment:

For a defect to qualify under the California Lemon Law, it must substantially impair the use, value, or safety of the vehicle. This criterion ensures that only significant issues, not minor inconveniences, fall under the protection of the law.

4. Number of Repair Attempts:

A crucial aspect is the number of repair attempts made by the manufacturer or its authorized repair facilities. If the same issue persists after a reasonable number of attempts, the vehicle may be considered a lemon.

Identifying Persistent Defects and Recurring Issues

1. Maintain Detailed Records:

Keep comprehensive records of all repairs and maintenance performed on the vehicle. This includes dates, descriptions of issues, and the steps taken to address them. Thorough documentation is crucial in establishing the history of defects.

2. Document Repair Attempts:

Specifically document each attempt made by the manufacturer or its authorized repair facilities to address the defects. Note the number of repair attempts and the specific components targeted in each instance.

3. Communication with Manufacturer:

Maintain clear communication with the manufacturer regarding the ongoing issues. Officially report the defects and provide an opportunity for the manufacturer to address the problems.

4. Seek a Second Opinion:

If issues persist, consider seeking a second opinion from an independent and qualified mechanic. An unbiased evaluation can provide additional evidence of recurring defects.

5. Review Manufacturer's Warranty:

Understand the terms of the manufacturer's warranty. If defects persist within the warranty period, it strengthens the case for lemon law protection.

Consumer Protections Under the Lemon Law

Lemon Law Presumptions Triggering Consumer Protections

1. Number of Repair Attempts:

If a defect persists after a manufacturer's reasonable number of repair attempts, a presumption arises that the vehicle is a lemon. This presumption is triggered when the manufacturer or its authorized repair facilities fail to resolve the issue despite repeated efforts.

2. Out-of-Service Duration:

Another significant presumption is related to the duration the vehicle is out of service for repairs. If the cumulative days the vehicle spends out of service due to repair attempts reach a certain threshold, the law presumes that the vehicle is a lemon. This recognizes the inconvenience caused to the consumer when the vehicle is continually in the repair shop.

3. Serious Safety Defects:

In cases involving serious safety defects that may cause death or serious bodily injury, a single repair attempt may trigger lemon law protections. This presumption acknowledges the heightened significance of safety-related defects.

Understanding the Manufacturer's Obligations for Repair, Replacement, or Refund

1. Repair Attempts:

The manufacturer or its authorized repair facilities must be given a reasonable number of attempts to fix the defects. If the defects persist after these attempts, the manufacturer is obligated to take further action.

2. Replacement Option:

If the defects cannot be fixed after a reasonable number of repair attempts, the manufacturer is obligated to offer the consumer the option of a replacement vehicle. The replacement vehicle should be substantially identical or, at the consumer's discretion, a comparable model.

3. Refund Option:

Alternatively, if the consumer prefers not to receive a replacement, the manufacturer must provide a refund. The refund typically includes the vehicle's purchase price, minus a reasonable allowance for use.

4. Reasonable Allowance for Use:

The reasonable allowance for use is a deduction from the refund amount to account for the consumer's use of the vehicle before the defects arose. This deduction is calculated based on the mileage at the time the consumer first reported the defects.

5. Compliance with Presumptions:

If the defects trigger the lemon law presumptions—such as a certain number of repair attempts or the vehicle being out of service for a specific duration—the manufacturer is obligated to comply with the resulting presumptions in favor of the consumer.

Steps to Take If Your Car Is a Lemon

Notifying the Manufacturer and Seeking Repairs

1. Review Your Warranty:

Familiarize yourself with the terms of your manufacturer's warranty. Understanding the coverage and any specific requirements for repairs is essential.

2. Notify the Manufacturer:

Report the defects to the manufacturer in writing. Clearly outline the issues, provide details of repair attempts, and include supporting documentation. Ensure that your notification is sent via certified mail with a return receipt requested to establish a record.

3. Allow for Repair Attempts:

Give the manufacturer or its authorized repair facilities a reasonable number of attempts to fix the defects. Be cooperative and provide access to the vehicle for inspections and repairs.

Understanding Your Options for Resolution

1. Replacement Vehicle:

The manufacturer may offer a replacement vehicle that is substantially identical to your current one. Alternatively, you may have the option to choose a comparable model.

2. Refund Option:

If you prefer not to receive a replacement, you have the right to a refund. The refund should include the full purchase price of the vehicle, minus a reasonable allowance for your use of the vehicle before the defects arose.

3. Reasonable Allowance Deduction:

Be aware that a reasonable allowance for use may be deducted from the refund amount. This deduction is calculated based on the mileage at the time you first reported the defects.

4. Legal Consultation:

Consider consulting with an attorney specializing in lemon law cases. Legal professionals can provide guidance on the best course of action and ensure that your rights are protected throughout the process.

What Happens Next: Resolution and Compensation

Manufacturer's Response to Lemon Law Claims

1. Evaluation and Verification:

Upon receiving your lemon law claim, the manufacturer will likely conduct an evaluation to verify the reported defects. This may involve further inspections, diagnostics, or communication with their authorized repair facilities.

2. Resolution Offer:

If the manufacturer acknowledges the validity of your lemon law claim, they may present you with a resolution offer. This offer may include options for a replacement vehicle or a refund, as stipulated by the California Lemon Law.

3. Negotiation or Rebuttal:

Consumers have the right to negotiate with the manufacturer regarding the terms of the resolution offer. If you disagree with the proposed solution or believe it is insufficient, you can present a rebuttal outlining your concerns and desired outcome.

Knowing When to Seek Legal Assistance

1. Unresolved Issues:

If the defects in your vehicle persist after multiple repair attempts, and the manufacturer has not provided a satisfactory resolution, it's time to consider legal assistance.

2. Manufacturer's Denial:

If the manufacturer denies the validity of your lemon law claim or offers an inadequate resolution, seeking legal guidance can help you assert your rights and negotiate a fair outcome.

3. Complex Cases:

Cases involving safety-related defects, significant out-of-service durations, or complex issues may benefit from legal expertise. Legal professionals can navigate the complexities of such cases more effectively.

4. Refusal of Replacement or Refund:

If the manufacturer refuses to offer a replacement vehicle or refund despite the persistence of defects, legal intervention may be necessary to enforce your rights.

5. Negotiation Challenges:

If you encounter challenges in negotiating with the manufacturer or feel overwhelmed by the process, an attorney can provide valuable assistance in advocating for your interests.

Seeking legal assistance can be a strategic move when faced with a challenging lemon law situation. Attorneys bring valuable expertise, negotiation skills, and the commitment to ensuring that consumers receive the compensation and resolution they deserve. 

‍